For Attorneys & CPAs · Legal Concepts
By Brad Caponigro · Founder, Pointer Petroleum LLC · Reservoir engineer
Published · Updated
In oil-and-gas states, land ownership is split into two estates: the surface estate and the mineral estate. The mineral estate includes everything beneath the surface — the oil, gas, coal, and other subsurface resources — along with a bundle of rights that let the owner develop or profit from those resources.
That bundle traditionally includes five sticks: the right to develop (drill and produce), the right to lease (grant development rights to an operator), the right to receive bonus payments, the right to receive delay rentals, and the right to receive royalties from production. Over time, courts and conveyances have grouped these sticks into two broad categories: executive rights and royalty rights. Because these categories can be separated — and frequently are — a mineral owner may hold one without the other.
Executive and royalty rights can be severed separately. Who owns each stick decides what happens at lease time — and who gets paid.
An executive right carries the power to sign the lease — and the bonus and delay rentals that come with it. Royalty rights travel separately; a holder who keeps only the royalty stick (an NPRI) gets a share of production but does not vote on whether the tract is leased, to whom, or at what rate. Each of these sticks can be sold, reserved, or fractionated independently.
Executive rights are the power to lease the mineral estate. The holder of executive rights decides whether to sign an oil and gas lease, which operator to sign with, and what terms the lease will contain — including the royalty rate, the primary term, the depth clause, and any surface-use restrictions.
In practical terms, executive rights give you a seat at the negotiating table. If an operator wants to drill on acreage that includes your minerals, the executive right holder is the person the landman calls. Without executive rights, you have no say in when or whether the minerals are leased, who leases them, or what the lease looks like.
Executive rights also typically carry the right to receive bonus payments and delay rentals, since those payments are consideration for signing (or extending) the lease itself. The executive right holder collects the bonus check at signing and receives delay rentals during any period the lease is maintained without production.
Royalty rights are the right to receive a share of production revenue once a well begins producing. If your minerals are leased and the operator drills a producing well, the royalty right entitles you to your fractional share of the oil and gas revenue — typically expressed as a fraction of production (for example, 1/8 or 3/16) without bearing any of the costs of drilling or operating the well.
Royalty rights are passive. The holder does not decide whether to lease, does not negotiate lease terms, and does not participate in development decisions. What the holder does receive is a check when production occurs, calculated according to the royalty rate in the lease that the executive right holder negotiated.
A royalty interest that has been severed from the executive right is commonly called a non-participating royalty interest, or NPRI. The "non-participating" label does not mean the interest is inactive or less valuable — it means the holder does not participate in lease negotiations. The royalty still pays as long as there is production.
Severance happens through a recorded instrument — usually a deed, but sometimes a will or a court order. The most common scenarios involve a mineral owner who wants to give away or sell the royalty stream while keeping control over leasing, or vice versa.
A typical severance looks like this: a mineral owner in the Permian Basin deeds to a family member "an undivided one-half (1/2) non-participating royalty interest" in a specific tract. The deed conveys the right to receive half the royalty income from that tract but expressly reserves executive rights to the grantor. The grantor retains the power to lease; the grantee receives royalty checks from production.
Severance can also happen the other way. An owner can convey executive rights (the power to lease) while retaining the royalty interest. This is less common but does occur — particularly in transactions between sophisticated parties or within family trusts.
Historical deeds are a frequent source of severed estates. Many mineral deeds recorded in the early and mid-twentieth century used boilerplate language that courts have since interpreted as creating NPRIs or reserving executive rights, sometimes in ways the original parties may not have anticipated. It is not unusual for title examination to reveal a severance that happened decades ago and has been carried forward through the chain of title ever since.
The key point: once executive rights and royalty rights are separated, they run independently through the chain of title. A subsequent sale or inheritance of the royalty interest does not carry executive rights unless the conveyance specifically includes them.
If you are considering selling a mineral interest, the first question a buyer will ask (after location and production) is what bundle of rights you actually own. An interest that includes both executive rights and royalty rights is a full mineral interest — the most valuable configuration, because the buyer gets both the income stream and the ability to negotiate future leases.
An NPRI — a royalty interest without executive rights — is still valuable, but it trades at a different level because the buyer cannot control lease terms. The NPRI holder depends on the executive right holder to negotiate favorable leases, and has limited recourse if the executive right holder signs a lease with a low royalty rate or unfavorable terms. (The executive right holder does owe a duty to the NPRI holder — more on that below — but the duty has practical limits.)
Conversely, holding executive rights without a royalty interest is unusual and generally less marketable, since the rights carry control but no direct production income.
When you request an offer from a buyer, include whatever information you have about the nature of your interest. A recent division order, the original deed or conveyance, or even a legal description from a tax statement can help a buyer determine what you own and provide an accurate valuation.
In most oil-and-gas states, the executive right holder owes a duty of utmost good faith and fair dealing to the non-participating royalty interest holder. This means the executive right holder cannot lease the minerals on terms designed to diminish the NPRI holder's royalty — for example, accepting a below-market royalty rate in exchange for a larger bonus payment that only the executive right holder keeps.
The scope of this duty varies by state. Texas courts have developed the most detailed body of case law on the subject. The Texas Supreme Court held in Manges v. Guerra, 673 S.W.2d 180 (Tex. 1984), that the executive owes the non-executive a duty of "utmost good faith and fair dealing," and subsequent decisions including Lesley v. Veterans Land Board, 352 S.W.3d 479 (Tex. 2011), have continued to apply that standard. Other producing states generally impose a similar obligation, though the specific standard and remedies differ.
In practice, disputes between executive right holders and NPRI holders often arise when a lease is signed with terms that appear to favor the executive right holder at the expense of the royalty interest. If you hold an NPRI and believe the executive right holder has leased your minerals on unreasonable terms, consulting an oil and gas attorney in the state where the minerals are located is the appropriate first step.
If you are not sure whether your mineral interest includes executive rights, here are a few ways to find out:
Read your deed or conveyance. The instrument that created your interest — whether a mineral deed, royalty deed, will, or court order — should describe what was conveyed and what was reserved. Language like "non-participating royalty interest" or "reserving unto grantor the executive rights" is a clear indicator of severance.
Check your division order. A division order from the operator will show your decimal interest in production but will not tell you whether you hold executive rights. However, it can confirm you are receiving royalties, which is a starting point.
Review the county records. The chain of title for your tract is recorded in the county clerk's office (or equivalent). A title search or title opinion can trace the ownership of executive rights and royalty rights separately through the chain.
Ask the operator or landman. If your minerals are currently leased, the operator's land department may be able to tell you who the lease was negotiated with (the executive right holder) and who receives royalties.
If you are uncertain about the nature of your interest and are considering a sale, a mineral buyer with title expertise can often determine what you own from public records as part of the evaluation process.
Executive rights are the power to lease the mineral estate — the holder decides whether to sign an oil and gas lease, with whom, and on what terms. Royalty rights are the right to receive a share of production revenue when a well produces. These two rights can be held by the same person (a full mineral interest) or separated into different ownership (creating a non-participating royalty interest for the royalty holder and an executive interest for the leasing party).
Yes. Executive rights can be separated from royalty rights through a recorded deed, will, or court order. The most common form of severance creates a non-participating royalty interest (NPRI), where one party holds the royalty right and another party holds the executive right. Once severed, the rights run independently through the chain of title.
Generally, yes. An NPRI receives royalty income from production, but the holder cannot negotiate lease terms, collect bonus payments, or receive delay rentals. The lack of control over lease negotiations — particularly the royalty rate — introduces a dependency on the executive right holder that reduces the interest's market value relative to a full mineral interest with the same production.
In most oil-and-gas states, the executive right holder owes a duty of utmost good faith and fair dealing to the NPRI holder. This means the executive right holder cannot negotiate lease terms designed to benefit themselves at the NPRI holder's expense — for example, accepting a low royalty rate in exchange for a higher bonus that only the executive right holder receives. The exact scope of this duty varies by state.
Review the deed, will, or court order that created your interest. If the instrument conveys a "non-participating royalty interest" or expressly reserves executive rights to the grantor, your interest does not include executive rights. If the instrument conveys "mineral rights" or a "mineral interest" without reservation, you likely hold both executive and royalty rights. A title search in the county records can confirm the current state of ownership if the original instrument is unclear.
Primary sources used in writing this article. These are not legal or tax advice — they are the public statutes, regulations, and authoritative materials the article draws from. Consult a qualified attorney or CPA before acting on any of them.
A non-executive mineral interest is real mineral ownership with one piece missing: the power to lease. That missing piece — held by someone else, often a relative or a stranger several deeds removed — shapes everything about what the interest pays, what it is worth, and what its owner can do about it.
A non-participating royalty interest is the most commonly misunderstood interest in oil and gas: its owner shares in production revenue but holds none of the other rights mineral owners take for granted. Understanding exactly what an NPRI includes — and excludes — determines what it is worth and how it can be sold.
Mineral interest, royalty interest, non-participating royalty interest, and overriding royalty interest are four different things, taxed differently, paid differently, and worth different amounts on the same well. Owners frequently sell or buy the wrong type because the names sound similar.
When mineral and surface ownership are split, each owner has distinct rights and limitations. This guide explains mineral dominance, the accommodation doctrine, and what each estate can actually do.